Who has won more, New York City or Toronto FC?

New York City lead the head-to-head with 13 wins to 9, plus 9 draws, over 31 meetings.

How many goals do New York City vs Toronto FC matches produce?

An average of 3.26 goals per meeting. More than 2.5 goals in 58% of them, and both teams scored in 58%.

vs Full meeting history, record and predictions

Our record on this fixture

100%

1 won, 0 lost of 1 settled tips

Head to head

Overall record

31 meetings

13 New York City9 DrawsToronto FC 9

Goals

52–49

Goals per match

3.26

Both teams scored

58%

Over 2.5 goals

58%

Clean sheets

6–7

Biggest win

5–0

At New York City

12 meetings

4 New York City6 DrawsToronto FC 2

Goals

21–21

Goals per match

3.50

Both teams scored

83%

Over 2.5 goals

67%

Clean sheets

1–1

Biggest win

0–5

At Toronto FC

13 meetings

4 New York City3 DrawsToronto FC 6

Goals

14–22

Goals per match

2.77

Both teams scored

46%

Over 2.5 goals

46%

Clean sheets

2–5

Biggest win

4–0

6 meetings at neutral venues are counted in the overall record only.

Every meeting

Date	Competition	Score	Venue
29 Aug 2026	Major League Soccer	Toronto FC 1–1 New York City Our prediction	BMO Field
31 Jul 2026	Major League Soccer	New York City 1–1 Toronto FC	Yankee Stadium
03 Jul 2025	Major League Soccer	New York City 3–1 Toronto FC	Yankee Stadium
26 Apr 2025	Major League Soccer	Toronto FC 0–1 New York City	BMO Field
11 May 2024	Major League Soccer	Toronto FC 2–3 New York City	BMO Field
16 Mar 2024	Major League Soccer	New York City 2–1 Toronto FC	Yankee Stadium
24 Sept 2023	Major League Soccer	New York City 3–0 Toronto FC	Neutral venue
26 Jul 2023	Leagues Cup	New York City 5–0 Toronto FC	Neutral venue
29 Apr 2023	Major League Soccer	Toronto FC 1–0 New York City	BMO Field
24 Apr 2022	Major League Soccer	New York City 5–4 Toronto FC	Neutral venue

Data updated 2026-09-06 05:37 UTC

vs Full meeting history, record and predictions

Our record on this fixture

Head to head

Overall record

At New York City

At Toronto FC

Every meeting

Head to head

Related pages

Our record on this fixture

Head to head

Overall record

At New York City

At Toronto FC

Every meeting

What the numbers say

Frequently asked