4 meetings at neutral venues are counted in the overall record only.
| Date | Competition | Score | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Aug 2026 | MLS Next Pro | Toronto FC II 2–0 New York City II Our prediction | York Lions Stadium |
| 24 Apr 2026 | MLS Next Pro | Toronto FC II 2–1 New York City II | York Lions Stadium |
| 19 Mar 2026 | MLS Next Pro | New York City II 0–5 Toronto FC II | Neutral venue |
| 31 Aug 2025 | MLS Next Pro | Toronto FC II 3–0 New York City II | York Lions Stadium |
| 16 Jul 2025 | MLS Next Pro | New York City II 1–0 Toronto FC II | Neutral venue |
| 15 May 2025 | MLS Next Pro | New York City II 3–0 Toronto FC II | Neutral venue |
| 15 Sept 2024 | MLS Next Pro | Toronto FC II 3–0 New York City II | York Lions Stadium |
| 11 Sept 2024 | MLS Next Pro | New York City II 1–1 Toronto FC II | Neutral venue |
| 12 Jun 2024 | MLS Next Pro | Toronto FC II 1–3 New York City II | York Lions Stadium |
| 15 Sept 2023 | MLS Next Pro | New York City II 3–3 Toronto FC II | Belson Stadium at St John's University |
Data updated 2026-09-10 15:10 UTC
15 meetings
Goals
22–27
Goals per match
3.27
Both teams scored
47%
Over 2.5 goals
67%
Clean sheets
3–5
Biggest win
0–5
4 meetings
Goals
10–7
Goals per match
4.25
Both teams scored
75%
Over 2.5 goals
75%
Clean sheets
0–1
Biggest win
4–1
7 meetings
Goals
7–14
Goals per match
3.00
Both teams scored
43%
Over 2.5 goals
71%
Clean sheets
1–3
Biggest win
3–0
100%
1 won, 0 lost of 1 settled tips
New York City II
Last 5 matches · 3W 0D 2L · 13–9
Toronto FC II
Last 5 matches · 3W 1D 1L · 11–10
New York City II
Season statistics · 26 played · 14W 0D 12L
Toronto FC II
Season statistics · 26 played · 13W 0D 13L